Creepy Love by Them Are Us Too Lyrics

[Verse 1]
Now that I know who you are
You don't seem so good for me anymore
Pieces you broke and left behind
It's so hard to tell which are yours
And which are mine

[Chorus]
Now I'm caught
Between two sides of a broken heart

[Verse 2]
You came and you left as soon as you could leave
Well I may be young, but I'm not naive
Don't know why I thought my heart was numb
I guess we both hoped the right time had come

[Chorus]
Now I'm caught
Between two sides of a broken heart